Table 1: Systemic review of the English language literature regarding anorectal avulsions and their management.
|
Case Reports |
Management of the anorectal avulsion |
Timing of anal reconstruction |
Outcome |
|
Mathieson and Mann, 1965 [2] |
Primary repair + presacral drainage + sigmoid loop colostomy |
Primarily at the first surgery (hemodynamically unstable) |
At 12 months, complete continence for stool and flatus |
|
Sharma et al., 2000 [3] |
Primary repair + presacral drainage + sigmoid loop colostomy |
At the first surgery, in the first 48h (hemodynamically stable) |
Discharged after 7 months. Normal continence |
|
Terrosu et al., 2011 [4] |
Anal reimplantation + pelvic drainage tubes + loop transverse colostomy |
In the first 24h (hemodynamically stable) |
At 24 months complete continence |
|
Rispoli et al., 2012 [5] |
Direct suture not possible, sigmoid loop colostomy + presacral drainage + traction of the anus with a Foley catheter |
Delayed at a second surgery, in the first 36h (hemodynamically stable) |
At 34 months, no incontinence. Anal canal with normal tone but dislocated cranially |
|
Hassani et al., 2013 [6] |
Primary repair + presacral drainage + sigmoid loop colostomy |
Primarily at the first surgery (hemodynamically stable) |
At 6 months, no physiologic dysfunction on anorectal manometry; anal stenosis requiring dilatations |
|
Gomes et al., 2013 [7] |
Direct repair not possible Sigmoid loop colostomy + distal loop washouts |
Delayed at 72h |
On 1 month, no tone of the anal sphincter, then loss to follow-up |
|
Barni et al., 2015 [8] |
Anal reimplantation + subcutaneous suction drainage + sigmoid loop colostomy |
Primarily at the first surgey (hemodynamically stable) |
Anal stenosis requiring perineal rehabilitation and repetitive anal dilatation |
|
Page et al., 2015 [9] |
Reimplantation not possible Diverting colostomy + perineal washout |
At 5th day, completion proctectomy and rectus abdominis myocutaneous flap |
Permanent stoma |
|
Cruceru et al., 2016 [10] |
Anal reimplantation + pelvic drainage + sigmoid loop colostomy |
Delayed at 48h (hemodynamically stable) |
At 6 months no impairment of the anal continence. |