Table 2: Summary of previously reported cases of mucoepidermoid carcinoma of the breast.
|
No |
Authors |
Year Published |
Age |
Grade |
Size (mm) |
Type of surgery |
Medical Approach |
LN procedure |
No of LN |
LN Status |
Follow up (m) |
Status |
Distant Metastasis |
|
1 |
Patchefsky 1 [19] |
1979 |
66 |
Low |
13 |
Radical Mastectomy |
NS |
AC |
0/ (20) |
Negative |
94 |
Died -other causes |
NS |
|
2 |
Patchefsky 2 [19] |
1979 |
70 |
Low |
50 |
Quadrectomy |
NS |
NS |
NS |
NS |
10 |
Alive |
NS |
|
3 |
Kovi [15] |
1981 |
46 |
High |
NA |
Radical Mastectomy |
NS |
AC |
17/ (19) |
Positive |
NS |
NS |
NS |
|
4 |
Fisher 1 [12] |
1983 |
65 |
Low |
NA |
WLE |
NS |
NS |
NS |
NS |
60 |
Alive |
NS |
|
5 |
Fisher 2 [12] |
1983 |
71 |
Low |
NA |
Radical Mastectomy |
NS |
AC |
0 / (19) |
Negative |
48 |
Alive |
NS |
|
6 |
Fisher 3 [12] |
1983 |
57 |
Low |
NA |
Radical Mastectomy |
NS |
AD |
0/ (11) |
Negative |
120 |
Alive |
NS |
|
7 |
Fisher 4 [12] |
1983 |
49 |
Low |
NA |
Radical Mastectomy |
NS |
AD |
0/ (13) |
Negative |
108 |
Alive |
NS |
|
8 |
Fisher 5 [12] |
1983 |
60 |
Low |
NA |
Radical Mastectomy |
NS |
NS |
NS |
NS |
48 |
Died -other causes |
NS |
|
9 |
Ratanarapee [21] |
1983 |
27 |
High |
NA |
Radical Mastectomy |
NS |
AD |
6/ (15) |
Positive |
14 |
Died -other causes |
NS |
|
10 |
Luchtrath [17] |
1984 |
81 |
Low |
NS |
Mastectomy |
NS |
NS |
NS |
NS |
NS |
NS |
NS |
|
11 |
Hanna 1 [13] |
1985 |
51 |
NA |
20 |
Modified Radical Mastectomy |
none |
NS |
0/ (ns) |
Negative |
8 |
Alive |
NS |
|
12 |
Hanna 2 [13] |
1985 |
31 |
NA |
NA |
Modified Radical Mastectomy |
Chemotherapy |
AC |
2/ (18) |
Positive |
14 |
Alive |
NS |
|
13 |
Hastrup [14] |
1985 |
59 |
High |
10 |
Modified Radical Mastectomy |
* |
SLNB |
0/ (4) |
Negative |
25 |
Died |
Recurrence Same Breast and New primary Controlateral Breast |
|
14 |
Leong [16] |
1985 |
57 |
High |
|
Radical Mastectomy |
NS |
AC |
0/ (20) |
Negative |
6 |
Died |
lung and spine |
|
15 |
Luchtrath [18] |
1989 |
60 |
High |
50 |
Radical Mastectomy |
Chemotherapy |
AC |
12/ (18) |
Positive |
30 |
Died |
Bone |
|
16 |
Pettinato [20] |
1989 |
72 |
High |
NA |
Mastectomy |
NS |
AC |
16/ (19) |
Positive |
few |
Died |
NS |
|
17 |
Berry [7] |
1996 |
51 |
High |
NA |
Mastectomy and primary reconstruction |
NS |
AC |
0/ (NS) |
Negative |
NS |
Alive |
NS |
|
18 |
Chang [11] |
1998 |
54 |
High |
NA |
Modified Radical Mastectomy |
Chemotherapy |
AD |
0/ (9) |
Negative |
48 |
Alive |
No |
|
19 |
Markopoulos [4] |
1998 |
40 |
High |
20 |
WLE |
Chemotherapy, Radiotherapy, Tamoxifen |
AD |
0/ (Level 1) |
Negative |
60 |
Alive |
No |
|
20 |
Tjalma [22] |
2002 |
49 |
low that recurrent as high |
35 |
Radical Mastectomy |
NS |
AC |
1/ (17) |
Positive |
156 |
Alive |
NS |
|
21 |
Di Tommaso 1 [26] |
2003 |
80 |
Low |
5 |
WLE |
NS |
NP |
NP |
NP |
5 |
Alive |
NS |
|
22 |
Di Tommaso 2 [26] |
2003 |
29 |
Low |
8 |
WLE |
NS |
NP |
NP |
NP |
90 |
Alive |
NS |
|
23 |
Di Tommaso 3 [26] |
2003 |
54 |
Low |
15 |
WLE |
NS |
AD |
0/ (NS) |
Negative |
13 |
Alive |
NS |
|
24 |
Di Tommaso 4 [26] |
2003 |
55 |
Intermediate |
6 |
WLE |
NS |
AD |
0/ (NS) |
Negative |
3 |
Alive |
NS |
|
25 |
Di Tommaso 5 [26] |
2003 |
36 |
High |
11 |
Quadrectomy |
NS |
AD |
0/ (NS) |
Negative |
18 |
Alive |
NS |
|
26 |
Aysen [23] |
2004 |
79 |
High |
80 |
Radical Mastectomy |
NS |
AD |
4/ (14) |
Positive |
NS |
NS |
NS |
|
27 |
Gomez Aracil [9] |
2006 |
69 |
High |
75 |
Radical Mastectomy |
Chemotherapy neo-adjuvant |
AC |
24/ (28) |
Positive |
NS |
NS |
NS |
|
28 |
Horii [3] |
2006 |
54 |
Low |
25 |
Mastectomy |
Aromatase Inhibitors |
AD |
0/ (NS) |
Negative |
36 |
Alive |
No |
|
29 |
Hornychova [1] |
2006 |
63 |
High |
18 |
Partial mastectomy |
Chemotherapy Radiotherapy |
AD |
0/ (17) |
Negative |
18 |
Alive |
No |
|
30 |
Hornychova [1] |
2006 |
30 |
Low |
82 |
Mastectomy |
Chemotherapy Radiotherapy |
AD |
0/ (NS) |
Negative |
60 |
Alive |
NS |
|
31 |
Camelo Piragua [25] |
2008 |
49 |
Intermediate |
15 |
Modified Radical Mastectomy |
Chemotherapy |
SLNB |
1/ (3+9) |
Positive |
8 |
Alive |
No |
|
32 |
Basbug [24] |
2011 |
69 |
High |
10 |
Mastectomy |
Chemotherapy Radiotherapy |
AD |
0/ (12) |
Negative |
12 |
Alive |
No |
|
33 |
Palermo [27] |
2013 |
80 |
High |
40 |
NS |
NS |
NS |
NS |
NS |
NS |
NS |
NS |
|
34 |
Turk [5] |
2013 |
40 |
NS |
55 |
Modified Radical Mastectomy |
Chemotherapy |
AC |
1/ (24) |
Positive |
5 |
Alive |
No |
|
35 |
Fujino [2] |
2016 |
71 |
Intermediate |
17 |
Mastectomy |
NS |
SLNB |
NS |
NS |
NS |
NS |
NS |
|
36 |
Sherwell-Cabello [6, 28] |
2016 and 2017** |
86 |
Low |
60 |
Modified Radical Mastectomy |
No |
NS |
NS |
NS |
3 |
Alive |
No |
|
37 |
Cheng 1 [8] |
2017 |
39 |
Low |
15 |
Modified Radical Mastectomy |
NS |
AC |
3/ (18) |
Positive |
NS |
Alive |
NS |
|
38 |
Cheng 2 [8] |
2017 |
49 |
Low |
15 |
Modified Radical Mastectomy |
NS |
AC |
0/ (17) |
Negative |
NS |
Alive |
NS |
|
39 |
Cheng 3 [8] |
2017 |
66 |
Low |
13 |
Mastectomy |
NS |
SLNB |
0/ (6) |
Negative |
NS |
Alive |
NS |
|
40 |
Cheng 4 [8] |
2017 |
61 |
Low |
30 |
Mastectomy |
NS |
SLNB |
0/ (3) |
Negative |
NS |
Alive |
NS |
|
41 |
Our |
2018 |
63 |
Low |
21 |
WLE |
NS |
SLNB |
0/ (5) |
Negative |
36 |
Alive |
NS |
*None at presentation. Chemotherapy, Radiotherapy and Endocrine Treatment was given when the malignancy recurred with metastasis **The same case was reported in 2 different papers by the same author. NS: not stated AC: axillary node clearance, AD: axillary dissection SLNB: sentinel lymph node biopsy, NA: not applicable, No: number, NP: not performed, WLE: wide local excision